• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Gateway Journalism Review

Published continuously since 1970

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Phone
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About GJR
  • News
    • Police Accountability Project
    • Midwest
    • Opinion
    • Media
  • Print issue
  • First Amendment Celebration
    • Watch: 11th Annual First Amendment Celebration

Look before you link

July 24, 2014 by Ben Lyons Leave a Comment

image_pdfimage_print

Editor’s Note: This is an opinion column by Ben Lyons. 

On July 19, the New York Times’ Nicholas Kristof wrote that “Hamas sometimes seems to have more support on certain college campuses in America or Europe than within Gaza,” (links original) in a column titled “Who’s right and wrong in the Middle East.” If you read the online version of his column, the first link (under the text “on certain college campuses…”) would send you to a Washington Post article on the American Studies Association’s backing an academic boycott of Israeli universities in December 2013.

On Twitter, a few readers asked Kristof about the link. Said Chase Madar (a lawyer and journalist, according to his bio): “The article that you link to about the ASA #BDS resolution does not even mention Hamas, by the way.”

Kristof’s reply was a stunner. He said “[I] write the column, and someone else chooses links later, so don’t read too much into the links except as further resources.”

For those following the exchange, this became the bigger story. For Jay Rosen, media critic and NYU professor of journalism, this news was “Not good. Not good at all.” Other readers offered more instructive critique.

The role of links has changed

Ward Harkavy, formerly of the Village Voice, said to Kristof, “This is 2014. Links are part of your copy in close ways that they weren’t last century. Should be chosen by you.”

Ahmed Al Omran, a Wall Street Journal correspondent, said “linking is an editorial choice, very much part of writing now.”

All links not created equal

Seline Jung, a journalist based in Boston, pointed out the obvious: While some links are simply tangential information, this one was vital to Kristof’s argument. “But that link is CRUCIAL in that it suggests further reference for the statement you made,” she said. “What DID you mean by ‘support for Hamas on college campuses in the US’? A new link or clarification for your statement is needed.”

At least be transparent

Matthew Richards, a photojournalist published in the Economist, the Wall Street Journal and the Guardian, suggested “perhaps you want to think about stating that at the end of the article?”

The readers are right. Kristof should be aware of the links in his articles, when so much news is consumed online – and should speak up is he disagrees with those employed. This is especially true in articles on highly charged topics, such as this one.

Journalists (especially those of Kristof’s stature) cannot abdicate responsibility here – conscientious use of hyperlinks has become an important, and undervalued, part of the job description.

A link is not (always) an “extra.” Often, links are like footnotes to support one’s argument, as one reader pointed out. Bad ones undermine it.

Author

  • Ben Lyons

    View all posts

Share our journalism
           

Filed Under: Media Tagged With: Hamas, hyperlinks, Nicholas Kristof, The New York Times

Archive of St. Louis Journalism Review

The St. Louis Public Library maintains an archive of our collection when Gateway Journalism Review was the St. Louis Journalism Review.

Primary Sidebar

Sign up for our weekly newsletter!

Don't miss original stories about local journalism happening between the coasts. We deliver media news from the Midwest to your inbox every Thursday afternoon.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Gateway Journalism Review, SIU Carbondale School of Journalism, Carbondale, IL, 62901, http://www.gatewayjr.org. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
No audio track to show. (Invalid input URL)

Life After Journalism


IRE Radio


Illinois News Broadcasters


Footer

11th Annual First Amendment Celebration featuring Evan Osnos

https://vimeo.com/704150392?loop=0

10th Annual First Amendment Celebration featuring Claire McCaskill

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vwtrmyauuBA

Listen to GJR’s Founder

Become a sustaining member or associate of GJR with a recurring or one-time donation that supports our journalism.

Copyright © 2023 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in